2018
 Ashley Toliver for Spectra (Coffee House Press)
 Judge: Jason Bayani
 •
 2017
 Bao Phi for Thousand Star Hotel (Coffee House Press)
 Judge: Sarah Menefee
 •
 2016
 Lauren Levin for The Braid (Krupskaya)
 Judge: Melissa Mack
 •
 2015
 Orlando White for LETTERRS (Nightboat Books)
 Judge: Patrick James Dunagan
•
 2014
 Hollie Hardy for How to Take a Bullet and Other Survival Poems (Punk Hostage)
 Judge: Mukta Sambrani 
•
 2013
 Alli Warren for Here Come the Warm Jets (City Lights Books)
 Judge: Laura Moriarty
 •
2012
 Stephen Ratcliffe for Selected Days (Counterpath)
 Judge: anonymous
•
 2011
 Wanda Coleman for The World Falls Away (University of Pittsburgh Press)
 Judge: Brenda Coultas
•
 2010
 Khaled Mattawa for Toqueville (New Issues/University of Michigan)
 Judge: Ravi Shankar
•
 2009
 Joseph Stroud for Of This World: New and Selected Poems (Copper Canyon)
 Judge: Peter Weltner
•
 2008
 Barbara Guest (awarded posthumously) for The Collected Poems of Barbara Guest (ed. Hadley Haden Guest, Wesleyan University Press)
 Judge: Eileen Tabios
•
 2007
 Noah Eli Gordon for Novel Pictorial Noise (Harper Books)
 Judge: Sesshu Foster
•
 2006
 Rigoberto Gonzalez for Other Fugitives and Other Strangers (Tupelo Press)
 Judge: Bhanu Kapil
•
 2005
 Dara Wier for Reverse Rapture (Verse Press)
 Judge: Stephen Rodefer
•
 2004
 Adrienne Rich for The School Among the Ruins (W.W. Norton)
 Judge: Mark McMorris
•
 2003
 Fanny Howe for Gone (University of California Press)
 Judge: Larry Kearney
•
 2002
 Truong Tran for dust and conscience (Apogee Press)
 Judge: Juan Felipe Herrera
•
 2001
 Anselm Hollo for Notes on the Attractions and Possibilites of Existence: Selected Poems 1965-2000 (Coffee House Press)
 Judge: Joanne Kyger
•
 2000
 Kevin Davies for Comp. (Edge Books)
 Judge: Kevin Killian
•
 1999
 Cole Swensen for Try (University of Iowa Press)
 Judge: Elizabeth Robinson
•
 1998
 Elaine Equi for Voice Over (Coffee House Press)
 Judge: Thom Gunn
•
 1997
 Belle Waring for Dark Blonde (Sarabande Books)
 Judge: Mark Doty
•
 1996
 Alicia Suskin Ostriker for The Crack in Everything (University of Pittsburgh Press)
 Judge: Toi Derricotte
•
 1995
 Robert Wrigley for In the Bank of Beautiful Sins (Penguin Books)
 Judge: James Tate
•
 1994
 Jane Hirschfield for The October Palace (HarperCollins)
 Judge: Alison Deming
•
 1993
 Barbara Guest for Defensive Rapture (Sun & Moon)
 Judge: Ann Lauterbach
•
 1992
 Julia Randall for The Path to Fairview: New and Selected Poems (Louisiana State University Press)
 Judge: Marilyn Hacker
•
 1991
 C.D. Wright for String Light (University of Georgia Press)
 Judge: Arthur Sze
•
 1990
 Carol Snow for Artist and Model (Atlantic Monthly Press)
 Judge: Nathaniel Mackey
•
 1989
 Luis J. Rodriguez for Poems Across the Pavement (Tía Chucha Press) and Adrian C. Louis for Fire Water World (West End Press)
 Judge: Jimmy Santiago Baca
•
 1988
 Leslie Scalapino for way (North Point Press)
 Judge: Alice Notley
•
 1987
 Lyn Hejinian for My Life (Sun & Moon)
 Judge: Michael Palmer
•
 1986
 Yusef Komunyakaa for I Apologize for the Eyes in My Head (Wesleyan University Press)
 Judge: David Henderson
•
 1985
 Ron Silliman for Paradise (Burning Deck)
 Judge: C.D. Wright
•
 1984
 Jackson Mac Low for Bloomsday (Station Hill Press) and Diane Ward for Never Without One (Roof Books)
 Judge: Barrett Watten
•
 1983
 Larry Eigner for Water/Places/A Time (Black Sparrow Press) and Laura Moriarty for Persia (Chance Additions)
 Judge: Beverly Dahlen
•
 1982
 Stephen Rodefer for Four Lectures (The Figures) and Gloria Frym for Back to Forth (The Figures)
 Judge: Anselm Hollo
•
 1981
 Alice Notley for How Spring Comes (Toothpaste Press) and John Hildebidle for The Old Chore (Alice James Books)
 Judges: Kathleen Fraser and Jack Marshall
•
 1980
 Sharon Olds for Satan Says (University of Pittsburgh Press)
 Judges: Sandra Gilbert and Mark Linenthal
•
